Earnest listening is the perfect alibi for having nothing to say, and everyone has already worked it out.
The line is for the person who has built an entire reputation on the quality of their attention. You lean in, you hold the eye contact, you offer the small encouraging noise at precisely the correct interval, and you have quietly convinced yourself that this is a gift rather than a hiding place. It is a hiding place. Listening is the one activity that demands nothing of you except presence, which is why you have made it your speciality and why you are so rarely asked what you actually think. Notice how the conversation turns and you have nothing to add but a summary of what has already been said. You are a mirror with a pulse. The sting sits in the word alibi, because it names the arrangement accurately. You were not being generous with your attention; you were using theirs to avoid the terror of contributing anything of your own. It lands best when you describe yourself as a good listener with that faint, saintly glow, or when you let somebody finish a thought you had no intention of answering. They were not being heard. They were being absorbed by a vacuum with excellent manners, and the room has been quietly working it out for years.